December 19, 2018

America’s Yo-Yo Diet in the Middle East

President Donald Trump’s decision to withdraw all U.S. troops from Syria is a mistake. But unlike so many of his other ill-considered moves, this one is completely conventional and consistent with the bad choices of past presidents.

For the past 20 years, U.S. foreign policy in the Middle East has resembled a yo-yo diet. We declare we have gotten too heavy in the region and need to spend more time on what really matters – China and, to a lesser extent, Russia. We announce we are leaving the region. We start to reduce our military presence and senior leaders spend more of their time on other topics.

This strategic decision is reinforced by politics. The American public is sick of fighting wars in the Middle East that make no sense, cost a lot of money and have nothing to do with their daily lives.

But inevitably we go too far. We diet too heavily too quickly in a way that is not sustainable. We leave ourselves vulnerable, most notably to terrorist attacks but also to other problems that jump to the front page of the news and create a political outcry at home to act. And so we respond by again binging on the Middle East until it’s time to try another extreme diet.

Read the full commentary in POLITICO.

  • Commentary
    • Foreign Policy
    • March 25, 2025
    U.S. Airstrikes Alone Can’t Dislodge the Houthis

    But any resolution to the Houthis, as tangled as they are in wider regional and global problems, needs a local solution....

    By Eitan Danon

  • Commentary
    • Foreign Policy
    • March 12, 2025
    Don’t Trust Russia to Mediate the Iran Nuclear Deal

    Preventing an Iranian nuclear weapon is of critical importance to U.S. security and the security of Israel and partners throughout the Middle East....

    By Jonathan Lord

  • Podcast
    • March 4, 2025
    Iraq’s Population Grows to 46 Million People Following Nationwide Census

    Iraq’s population now stands at 46 million people following a nationwide census that was held in November of 2024. The census, the first in 40 years, has been billed as a succ...

    By Hamzeh Hadad

  • Commentary
    • The National Interest
    • February 16, 2025
    Gaza After Hamas

    To permanently remove Hamas from power, the United States must work alongside its Arab and Israeli partners to support the PA’s return to Gaza....

    By Delaney Soliday

View All Reports View All Articles & Multimedia